Bagels Your Way Cafe

2799 NY-112 # 8, Medford, NY 11763, United States
+1 631-758-6467
$$$ Bagel shop , Bakery , Breakfast restaurant , Cafe , Deli , Takeout restaurant , Vegetarian cafe and deli
(542 Reviews)
Price Range $10–20

Bagels Your Way Cafe sits comfortably in Medford as a casual spot built around New York’s classic bagel culture. More than just a bagel shop, it serves up a variety of breakfast sandwiches, deli-style subs, and fresh baked goods that fit well into a busy morning or a quick lunch stop.

The atmosphere inside is straightforward and welcoming, with a team focused on quick, friendly service. Locals seem to rely on it as a convenient pick-up spot, often calling ahead to avoid waits, though some choose to linger and enjoy their meal on site. The clientele ranges from folks grabbing a fast bite before heading off to work, to customers who appreciate a no-fuss place where the emphasis is on solid, familiar flavors packed with no-nonsense quality.

Menu highlights like pastrami sandwiches and standout baked treats such as Reese’s stuffed cookies and burnt rolls speak to a willingness to mix classic deli offerings with a few unique, indulgent touches. While most sandwiches come with expectations of all the usual fixings, occasional busy times can lead to minor oversights, but the friendly staff and steady rhythm of service keep things moving smoothly.

This cafe works best early in the day, especially on weekday mornings when grabbing a fresh breakfast sandwich or a bagel loaded your way fits neatly into a quick routine. It’s the kind of place appreciated by Medford residents who enjoy that authentic New York bagel experience without the rush of a city deli—an anchor of simple, reliable fare with a hometown vibe.

What they serve
Serves coffee
Best for
Serves breakfast
Accessibility
Has wheelchair-accessible car park
Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
Has wheelchair-accessible seating
Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot

Openings Hours

Checking

Monday

6:00 AM - 3:30 PM

Tuesday

6:00 AM - 3:30 PM

Wednesday

6:00 AM - 3:30 PM

Thursday

6:00 AM - 3:30 PM

Friday

6:00 AM - 3:30 PM

Saturday

6:00 AM - 3:00 PM

Sunday

6:00 AM - 3:00 PM

542 Reviews
Nadjamy Jean-Claude

09 Dec 2025

This is my go to deli when I'm in the mood for that NY style yummy fresh bagels, breakfast sandwich and hero sandwich subs. Also the baked goods are amazing. When I can I dine in however I usually call in my order to pick up. So proud to have this establishment in the community. Great team and service. Thanks for all the work you put in day in after day. Grace and Peace

A

07 Dec 2025

here is a review for Bagels Your Way: A Gem in Medford! I stopped by Bagels Your Way for a quick bite and was blown away by the experience. The service was super fast, and my order was hot and fresh, exactly what I was hoping for. It's the perfect spot when you need something quick and easy without sacrificing quality. The owner, JR, and his crew are the real stars here. Their customer service is top-notch, and they made me feel incredibly welcome from the moment I walked in. I ordered a hero, and it was perfectly cooked – the bread was toasted just right, and it was loaded with delicious onions and all the fixings. To top it all off, I even got a free cookie! It was a small gesture that made a big impression. With such great food and a friendly atmosphere, I will definitely be coming back. Highly recommended!

CB

20 Nov 2025

Went here to grab breakfast on a Saturday morning. Got two sausage, egg, and cheese sandwiches with salt, pepper, ketchup. We were very excited to try it, but were disappointed when we got home to find no salt, pepper, or ketchup in either sandwich and stale rolls. Giving them the benefit of the doubt that it was very busy in there. Besides that, the staff were very friendly! Would definitely try again.

Join the Bagels Your Way Cafe Newsletter

Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.